Today I was walking a few feet behind a young man with a
baby in a sling on my way home from a little exercise/podcast listening. A homeless man I know approached us from the
other side of Main Street, smiling and commenting how lucky I was that my
husband was taking care of the baby while I listened to music. He didn’t notice
that I am old enough to be the father’s mother, or the confused look on the
young man’s face. Because I know the homeless man, I also know that he is in the early stages of Alzheimer’s disease and is facing it with a lot of grace and … friendliness. He introduces himself to me regularly when he
stops by the house for breakfast. He is funny and kind and accepting of a
difficult diagnosis. While waiting for the light to turn green, I mentioned this
to the guy with the baby. He remained annoyed.
Earlier this week, I had the opportunity to speak for another man with mental issues, although he’s never had a diagnosis. “Ian” is in his mid-30s and has been homeless for most of the last ten years I’ve known him. He’s “not quite right in the head,” has trouble following simple instructions, and thinks “President George Bush” talks to him. He passes for normal on the street, unless you have a conversation with him, in which case you may become annoyed. He talks nonsense, non-stop, and doesn’t read your bored or aggravated body language. You might decide to report him to someone in authority – the librarian, the store-owner, campus security - and they will tell him to leave, which he won’t do because he is “a U.S. citizen with rights.” If the police are called, he will go to jail. And then he will be let out. And then it will happen again. The last time he was arrested, it was right in front of our house and the arresting officer said he had “a rap sheet a mile long” – mostly trespass. Because I saw what happened, I decided to see if I could help.
He had been sleeping in the empty lot across the street and, just as the sun was coming up, the owner of the lot happened to see him and tell him to leave – with the usual consequences. The owner called the police, Ian started to run away, and he was hauled in for trespassing plus resisting arrest. It's already an unjust situation. That particular lot is ground zero on Friday and Saturday nights for all kinds of illegal activity involved with the bar scene downtown. On Monday morning, there are open bottles and red plastic cups littering the lot. We have called the police a few times when fights have broken out; there have even been shootings in the vicinity. I wonder if the owner of the lot has ever intervened during those hours. Assisting college kids in getting drunk is good for downtown business. People sleeping in the bushes is not.
Ian, who doesn’t use alcohol or drugs and is not violent, has been in jail for the better part of the new year because of this and has yet to be evaluated for mental competency. I am continuing to bug his lawyer(s); he has had three so far (apparently the nature of the public defender’s office), all of whom have agreed that he should be evaluated, none of whom have been particularly helpful in moving the situation forward. Even the routine things – like following through on the order required to actually have him released from the jail after the judge officially did so in court (on the condition he stay with us and we do our best to get him to his next court appearance) - is still in process after two and a half days. Maybe there is just no hope for help from the state, no system in place to assist mentally ill people who don’t have money or family to look out for them – a lack of public funding, or public defenders, or social workers, or group homes. Maybe serial incarceration is just the best we can do.
I don’t really believe this; we could, after all, house Ian in a very nice hotel every night for less than the daily cost of imprisoning him. But even if the wheels of justice are just incredibly slow and unwieldy for some, couldn’t we at least be kind to people who are suffering through this stuff? We were at a major intersection in broad daylight when the guy with Alzheimer’s behaved, perhaps, in an overly-friendly manner to a stranger (heaven forbid). And Ian was over-sleeping quietly in an unused lot after having been kept awake by bar noise (and possible harassment by patrons) the night before. Are empathy and compassion possible in these situations, instead of fear and anger? When justice is hard to come by, is it possible to offer a little mercy?
{image: photo by Jack Couch of the statue "Justice and Mercy" at the Cumberland School of Law in Birmingham, Alabama}